Civic Watch

HRDC, Ngora and the test of accountability

The decision by the NGO Regulatory Authority (Ngora) to deregister 36 non-governmental organisations (NGOs), including the Human Rights Defenders Coalition (HRDC), has sparked considerable public debate. It has once again exposed the historically strained relationship between government and the civil society movement in Malawi — a relationship that has often resembled a game of Tom and Jerry, marked by suspicion, confrontation and mistrust.

As a human rights and governance advocate, I find this development deeply concerning. A functioning democracy needs a vibrant, independent civil society. My concern is also rooted in my personal and professional history within Malawi’s human rights movement.

I have longstanding relationships with some of the individuals who have helped shape this movement. They include Timothy Mtambo, who succeeded me at the Centre for Human Rights and Rehabilitation (CHRR); Gift Trapence; and Reverend Macdonald Sembereka, with whom I have worked closely. I have also played a role in nurturing the current generation of human rights leaders, including HRDC’s current chairperson, Michael Kayitsa.

These relationships are part of my contribution to the growth of civil society in Malawi. They do not disappear with changing political circumstances or differences of opinion.

However, professional relationships with individuals in the movement should not be mistaken for blanket endorsement of every position taken by organisations such as HRDC.

Indeed, I have often disagreed with HRDC’s approaches to advocacy. During President Peter Mutharika’s first administration, particularly in the period surrounding the 2019 elections and the subsequent electoral dispute, I was labelled a DPP cadet for advocating peaceful engagement as a way of resolving national disagreements. My position was misunderstood. I have never believed that defending human rights requires abandoning dialogue or peaceful engagement.

That conviction remains unchanged, including under the Tonse Alliance administration. Malawi cannot afford a political and civic culture in which every disagreement descends into confrontation. The country faces serious socioeconomic challenges, but these call for engagement, dialogue and constructive solutions.

We must also appreciate that the advocacy methods and strategies that may have been relevant in 2011 or 2019 cannot simply be replicated in 2026. Times have changed, circumstances are different and the challenges confronting the country have evolved. Civil society must adapt accordingly.

Against this background, HRDC’s deregistration raises two fundamental accountability questions.

The first concerns the responsibility of HRDC and the other affected organisations to meet their statutory obligations. The law applies to every organisation, irrespective of its public profile, influence or advocacy mandate.

As an organisation that demands transparency, accountability and good governance from government, HRDC must uphold those same standards in its own affairs. Any failure to meet statutory reporting requirements raises legitimate questions, and the organisation should not expect preferential treatment. Accountability cannot be demanded of others while being treated as optional at home.

The second question concerns the responsibility of government and Ngora in exercising regulatory powers. Regulation must not become a convenient instrument for silencing critical voices or weakening organisations that hold those in power accountable.

Given HRDC’s outspoken criticism of government, its inclusion among the deregistered organisations inevitably raises questions about the grounds for the decision. Ngora must be prepared to answer those questions convincingly and demonstrate that its action was based on objective regulatory considerations, not political expediency. This is particularly important in light of concerns raised by some civil society organisations about the fairness and proportionality of the regulatory process.

But there is a further issue that deserves attention: the future relevance and effectiveness of HRDC itself.

Malawi needs a strong human rights movement whose work goes beyond opposing government. Such a movement must defend citizens’ rights, promote accountability, strengthen democratic institutions and contribute constructively to national development.

HRDC should therefore use this moment for serious institutional reflection and reform, including putting its governance and administrative affairs in order. Being vocal does not necessarily translate into effectiveness. Nor should demonstrations become the default response to every national challenge.

My message is straightforward: HRDC must demonstrate the standards of governance and transparency it demands from government. Ngora must exercise its regulatory mandate fairly and impartially. And government must respect civic space and recognise the legitimate role of independent civil society organisations.

Malawi needs a strong, independent civil society and a government prepared to listen to criticism. Equally, civil society must recognise that effective leadership is not measured by how often it confronts government, but by how consistently it advances citizens’ interests and the broader national good.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Check Also
Close
Back to top button